Frequently Asked Question
Can Employers Drug Test In-House?
Employers are lawfully allowed to implement in-house drug testing programs (with some exceptions) to maintain a safe and drug-free workplace. Compared to outsourcing, in-house drug and alcohol testing can be more efficient and financially beneficial.
Legal and Practical Advantages of On-Site Drug Testing
In-house drug testing provides an immediate and flexible approach to ensuring a drug-free environment in the workplace. It's important to understand the distinction between DOT and non-DOT drug testing:
-
DOT (Department of Transportation) Drug Testing: This pertains to specific regulations the U.S. Department of Transportation sets. It is mandatory for certain safety-sensitive positions, primarily in the transportation industry, such as truck drivers, pilots, and railroad workers. DOT tests have strict protocols regarding the drugs tested for, the testing methods, and how results are reported. Instant and point-of-collection (POC) drug tests are not authorized for DOT drug testing. An employer can run its own DOT collection site with qualified collectors, but every DOT urine or oral fluid specimen must be screened and confirmed at an HHS-certified laboratory (49 CFR 40.210, 40.81), and a Medical Review Officer must verify the result before any action is taken.
-
Non-DOT Drug Testing: These tests are not bound by DOT regulations and can be tailored to an organization's needs. While they ensure a safe and productive work environment, they don't have the stringent requirements of DOT tests. Instant on-site screening can be used for non-DOT tests where state law allows it. A non-negative screen should be sent to a laboratory for confirmation before any action is taken, and some states require this.
Drawbacks of Outsourced Drug Testing
Using an external lab can be cumbersome and expensive. It involves coordinating with the lab, incurring service costs, and potentially dealing with timing challenges for post-incident tests. In an accident, for example, waiting for a lab technician to arrive may delay testing, and substances like alcohol might no longer be detectable. After-hours services can also lead to significant additional charges.
Economic and Operational Benefits of In-House Testing
In-house testing, however, addresses these issues. By training existing staff to conduct these tests, employers get timely results at a fraction of the cost. Per-test costs vary by test type, vendor and volume.
The lower cost is due to eliminating the need for an on-site technician visit from the lab, which adds to the expense of outsourced services. State-specific protocols and additional procedures can add to the cost.
Immediate Action for Safety
Most importantly, on-site testing facilitates rapid response when safety is concerned. If a non-DOT screen returns a non-negative result, immediate safety steps can be taken while the laboratory confirms it, as company policy and state law allow. For DOT tests, an employee may not be removed from safety-sensitive duty based on an unverified drug test result (49 CFR 40.21). This level of responsiveness is not achievable with external testing, where waiting for results could pose unnecessary risks.
DOT alcohol tests can be done on-site by a qualified screening test technician (STT) or breath alcohol technician (BAT) using a device on ODAPC's approved lists (49 CFR 40.211, 40.229). DOT drug tests cannot use instant tests and must be analyzed at an HHS-certified laboratory (49 CFR 40.81).
We are not a law firm. The information on this website is for informational purposes only and may not be up to date. Always consult a licensed attorney for personalized legal advice.