Frequently Asked Question
What Must an Employer Do When an Arbitrator Overturns a DOT Drug or Alcohol Test Result?
When an arbitrator purports to overturn a DOT drug or alcohol test result on grounds that DOT rules do not recognize, the employer must not return the employee to safety-sensitive functions until the employee completes the return-to-duty process. The DOT Office of Drug and Alcohol Policy and Compliance (ODAPC) states: "Such a test result remains valid under DOT regulations, notwithstanding the arbitrator's decision." The examples ODAPC gives are a disagreement with the medical review officer's (MRO's) judgment about a legitimate medical explanation and a procedural error that is not enough to cancel a test (49 CFR 40.209).
For a verified drug test result, the MRO alone can change it (49 CFR 40.149(c)). Part 40 says that "an arbitrator is not permitted to overturn the medical judgment of the MRO". ODAPC explains that an arbitrator draws authority from the employer or a labor-management agreement and cannot use authority that the employer lacks. An arbitrator may still find that a test should be cancelled because of a defect in the process involving the MRO, such as failing to offer the employee a verification interview.
The employer may still be bound by the personnel outcome of the arbitration. ODAPC acknowledges that this can create hardship, such as paying an employee whom DOT rules keep from performing the duties of the job. Refusal consequences cannot be overturned by an arbitration or other non-Federal forum (49 CFR 40.191(c) and 40.261(b)), as the DOT drug test refusal FAQ explains.
Related FAQ: When Is a DOT Alcohol Test Considered a Refusal?
Related FAQ: Can an Employer Fire an Employee Who Tests Positive or Refuses a DOT Test?
We are not a law firm. The information on this website is for informational purposes only and may not be up to date. Always consult a licensed attorney for personalized legal advice.