Frequently Asked Question
When Is a DOT Alcohol Test Considered a Refusal?
A DOT alcohol test is considered a refusal when an employee does any of the things listed in 49 CFR 40.261(a). These include failing to appear for a test within a reasonable time after the employer directs it (other than a pre-employment test), failing to remain at the testing site until the testing process is complete, failing to provide an adequate amount of breath or saliva, and failing to sign the certification at Step 2 of the Alcohol Testing Form (ATF). The list also reaches an employee who fails to give a sufficient breath specimen when a required medical evaluation finds no adequate medical explanation, and an employee who fails to undergo that examination or evaluation. The final item is a catch-all: "Fail to cooperate with any part of the testing process" (49 CFR 40.261(a)(7)).
An employee who leaves the collection site before the testing process starts for a pre-employment test is not deemed to have refused. For other tests, if an employee leaves before the process is complete, the employer must decide whether the conduct was a refusal. The breath alcohol technician (BAT) or screening test technician (STT) stops that part of the process, writes the conduct on the Remarks line of the ATF and notifies the designated employer representative (DER) immediately and directly. The rule says "the employer has the sole responsibility to decide whether a refusal occurred" (49 CFR 40.261(c)(2)).
A refusal carries the consequences that the relevant DOT agency rule sets for a violation of that rule. Part 40 adds that an arbitration, grievance, State court or other non-Federal forum cannot overturn or set aside those consequences (49 CFR 40.261(b)). Refusing a non-DOT test or a non-DOT form is not a refusal of a DOT test (49 CFR 40.261(d)). This answer covers alcohol tests only. Refusals of DOT drug tests follow a separate section, 49 CFR 40.191.
Related FAQ: Can an Employee Refuse a DOT Test Because the Selection Seems Unfair?
Related FAQ: What Must an Employer Do When an Arbitrator Overturns a DOT Drug or Alcohol Test Result?
We are not a law firm. The information on this website is for informational purposes only and may not be up to date. Always consult a licensed attorney for personalized legal advice.